O problema da objetividade no positivismo inclusivo a tese da incorporação como resposta às críticas de Dworkin
Carregando...
Tipo
TCC
Data de publicação
2023-12
Periódico
Citações (Scopus)
Autores
Grossmann, Tomás Tresoldi
Orientador
Camillo, Carlos Eduardo Nicoletti
Título da Revista
ISSN da Revista
Título de Volume
Membros da banca
Programa
Resumo
Este artigo objetivou identificar e analisar as respostas fornecidas pelo Positivismo
Inclusivo [ILP] às críticas desferidas por Ronald Dworkin contra a tradição do Positivismo,
além de identificar os principais problemas dessas respostas e suas possíveis soluções, com
enfoque especial para os problemas da objetividade e discricionariedade. Para isso, o método
usado foi o dedutivo e monográfico com técnica bibliográfica, através do enfrentamento
crítico dos principais textos sobre o tema. Por fim, conclui-se que o Positivismo Inclusivo
apresenta poucas vantagens e muitas desvantagens para a tradição Positivista, e que o preço
de sua adoção é o abandono ou flexibilização de muitos dos cometimentos centrais do
Positivismo do séc. XX.
This article aimed to identify and analyze the responses provided by Inclusive Positivism [ILP] to the objections raised by Ronald Dworkin against the Positivist tradition, as well as to pinpoint the main problems of these responses and their potential solutions, with a special focus on the problems of objectivity and adjudication. To achieve this, the deductive and monographic method was employed, along with bibliographic techniques, through a critical examination of the main texts on the subject. In conclusion, it is found that Inclusive Positivism presents few advantages and many disadvantages for the Positivist tradition, and that the cost of its adoption is the abandonment or flexibilization of many of the central commitments of 20th-century Positivism.
This article aimed to identify and analyze the responses provided by Inclusive Positivism [ILP] to the objections raised by Ronald Dworkin against the Positivist tradition, as well as to pinpoint the main problems of these responses and their potential solutions, with a special focus on the problems of objectivity and adjudication. To achieve this, the deductive and monographic method was employed, along with bibliographic techniques, through a critical examination of the main texts on the subject. In conclusion, it is found that Inclusive Positivism presents few advantages and many disadvantages for the Positivist tradition, and that the cost of its adoption is the abandonment or flexibilization of many of the central commitments of 20th-century Positivism.
Descrição
Trabalho indicado pela banca examinadora para o prêmio TCC
Palavras-chave
positivismo inclusivo , moral e direito , Ronald Dworkin , objetividade da lei , inclusive positivism , morality and law , objectivity of the law , incorporation thesis